How to compare mobile reception on two handsets
A fair comparison starts with a matching carrier, place, time and task, plus the exact regional model of each phone.

Two phones with similar product names can be different regional variants. Their supported mobile technologies and bands can differ. Reception can also change with the serving network and surroundings, so results from different carriers or buildings say little about which handset works better in the same conditions.
For a local comparison, note each model number and carrier, turn off Wi-Fi and repeat the same ordinary task at the same spot. Record what happened, including whether a page loaded or a call connected. Keep signal bars as supporting observations: manufacturers can present received-signal information differently.